There are many mysteries surrounding this family. Existence of 3 wives from History of Shelby & Moultrie Counties., Illinois, 1881. Children are assigned according to the listed death dates of the various wives. From this information, "Alexander McCoy Jr." estate in Brown Co. would likely pertain to Alexander son of George, and not, as William Perry indicates, to Alexander McCoy the immigrant. Several of the children were married in Brown Co., IL 1860-1861 by Joseph Patterson, JP.
But how, then, to explain the guardian's bond dated 19 may 1862, in which Alexander McCoy and Abner (?) Curry are appointed as guardians of Sarah Jane McCoy and Thomas Jefferson McCoy, minor heirs of Alexander McCoy, late of Brown County, Illinois, but the word deceased lined out? (Brown Co., IL Guardian's Bonds A, p. 19). The preceding bond, issued 18 mar 1862, was for the appointment of Alexander McCoy and Alford Simpson as guardians of Alexander McCoy, minor heir of George McCoy, late of said county, deceased. Evidently, the bond of 19 may 1862 is in error, the word late should have been lined out as well, and the guardianship is for some other purpose, such as a bequest from the late mother of these children.
[6388] Birthdate from census records. Tombstone says 1816. So far, no exact death date has been found.
[6389] According to pedigree chart of William V. Perry, Liberty, IL. Refers to McCoy cemetery, section 16, Cold Spring Tp., Shelby Co., IL. 1870shelbyco: Alexr&mrs.ann sarah susan wm mary/
[6390] Cemetery said to be in Section 16.
[14845] Likely married in Adams Co., OH, where records later than 1833 were lost in a courthouse fire. Emily Hemphill is likely related to Rachel Hemphill who m. John Morrison and moved to Shelby Co., IL -- where Alexander later lived.
[14846] Brown Co. marriage records Book A, #400. As the marriage is in 1847, after the birthdates of the first 7 children listed in the 1850 census, they are assumed to belong to his first wife, Emily Hemphill.
[14847] Assumed to have married in Brown Co., IL, because Hist. Shelby & Moultrie Cos., IL indicates they settled in Shelby Co., IL in 1864. She is mentioned in a Brown Co., IL deed on 09apr1862.
__ | _____________________| | | | |__ | _Alexander MCCOY ____| | (1770 - 1841) m 1796| | | __ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |__ | | |--Alexander MCCOY | (1815 - 1897) | __ | | | _Samuel MCCULLOUGH __| | | (.... - 1804) | | | |__ | | |_Hannah MCCULLOUGH __| (.... - 1815) m 1796| | __ | | |_____________________| | |__
In addition to the information found in his probate case file, Mary E. Fouts has found what appear to be probate minutes, described in an e-mail of 25 jul 2001:
Hello John,
I spent quite a few hours in Mt. Sterling, IL today (Brown County). I found an answer for myself and hope it adds to your information. It was not included in the material you had sent me anyway.
George McCoy died "on or about 1 July 1860." "His only son, Alexander McCoy, jr. died about 28 September 1866." George also left a widow, Lorinda McCoy listed as "step mother" of Alexander McCoy, jr. Lorinda got her dowers right and some land was left to Alexander. My marriage records for Brown County does not go far enough to find it.
When Alexander, jr. died (about 28 September, 1866) it listed his heirs — I had seen a list of everyone getting a portion of his estate, but this was listed differently and explained why so many names were listed as heirs. It gave the relationship:
GEORGE McCOY
Heirs listed:
Samuel (uncle)
Alexander Sr. (uncle)
Mary Smith, Mrs. John (aunt)
Eliza J. Perry, Mrs. Luke, Sr. (aunt)
Sarah Alexander, Mrs. Isaia (aunt)
NANCY WHEELER
Charles Wheeler (uncle)
Sidney Wheeler (uncle)
John Wheeler (uncle)
Polly Tolle, Mrs. Caleb (aunt)
Minerva Draper, Mrs. Allen (aunt)
Allen Wheeler, deceased (uncle)
"Allen's unknown heirs"
The list of heirs, properly termed "heirs-at-law", has a very specific implications. First, it requires that Alexander did not leave a will—heirs-at-law should come into play only when the deceased did not leave a will. Second, it is certain that Alexander McCoy left no living siblings, and no siblings who left living descendants, otherwise these would have been named in preference to the heirs of his parents. We therefore conclude that his brother Sidney who appears on the 1850 census had already died. Further, his aunts and uncles could not have been named as heirs-at-law unless his parents, George McCoy and Nancy Wheeler McCoy, had already died. Only after it is determined that there are no survivors of these closer degrees of relationship can the siblings of the parents, or the descendants of these siblings, be considered as heirs-at-law. Thus, the list of heirs should provide a complete list of all the living siblings of the full blood (half-siblings appear to have been excluded at that period) on both sides of the family. Since John Wingate McCoy is not listed, even though he was living in 1867, we can conclude that he was not a sibling of the full blood to Samuel, George, Alexander, Mary, Eliza, and Sarah McCoy. We can also be sure that Mary McCoy Smith, who has been so difficult to locate, had not remarried at that date.
The implications of this estate for the parentage of John Wingate McCoy depend on whether half-siblings were considered on equal footing with full siblings for the purposes of establishing the heirs-at-law in Illinois in the 1860's. It is our understanding that they would be excluded, but we have not found a clear statement of the law or a suitable case that demonstrates this point.
The Brown Co. Probate Record vol. 3 p. 226 shows that George W. McCoy (he is the son of Samuel, and thus a first cousin of the Alexander who had recently died) came before the probate court on 08 oct 1866 and made a bond to administer the estate of Alexander McCoy Jr. The next action was 17 dec 1866, when various claims against the state were approved: John A. Givens, $3.50; Joseph S. Glass, $2.65; Mary Smith, $105.00 (after hearing testimony of James Aber); James Aber, $30.00; E. A. Gordley, $106.06; James Putman, $19.00; Allen & Stoner, $25.50. On 18 dec 1866, Alexander's guardian A. A. Curry presented an accounting of assets he held on behalf of his late ward: a note on Joseph Harper for $400, 20 aug 1864, valued at $306.00; a note on Alexander McCoy the said deceased 25 nov 1865 valued at $273; a note on W. C. Marvin, H. W. Weaver, and John A. Marvin, valued at $52.00; and cash on hand $127.13, from which were deducted several numbered vouchers totaling $80.27.
[6371] this is the Alexander found living with A. D. Draper and Minerva Wheeler Draper in 1850 census of Brown Co., IL (#600). There is also a Sidney McCoy b. 1849 IL, of whom no further record.
[6372] Date given in records of the probate of his estate, Brown Co., IL.
_____________________ | _Alexander MCCOY ____| | (1770 - 1841) m 1796| | |_____________________ | _George MCCOY _______| | (1807 - 1860) m 1846| | | _Samuel MCCULLOUGH __ | | | (.... - 1804) | |_Hannah MCCULLOUGH __| | (.... - 1815) m 1796| | |_____________________ | | |--Alexander MCCOY | (1847 - 1866) | _____________________ | | | _John WHEELER _______| | | (.... - 1850) | | | |_____________________ | | |_Nancy WHEELER ______| (1821 - 1867) m 1846| | _____________________ | | |_Mary _____ _________| (1787 - 1850) | |_____________________
_Isaac MCCOY ________ | (1756 - 1797) _Thomas Jefferson MCCOY _| | (1789 - 1861) m 1825 | | |_Lydia GADDIS _______ | (1766 - 1824) _George Washington T. MCCOY _| | (1836 - 1887) m 1865 | | | _Reuben SMITH _______ | | | (1767 - 1840) m 1788 | |_Mary Ann D. SMITH ______| | (1805 - 1892) m 1825 | | |_Sarah Beach CLARK __ | (1773 - 1834) m 1788 | |--Alexander MCCOY | (1867 - ....) | _____________________ | | | _________________________| | | | | | |_____________________ | | |_Harriette CROWS ____________| (1840 - ....) m 1865 | | _____________________ | | |_________________________| | |_____________________
__ | _Isaac MCCOY ________| | (1756 - 1797) | | |__ | _Thomas Jefferson MCCOY _| | (1789 - 1861) m 1825 | | | __ | | | | |_Lydia GADDIS _______| | (1766 - 1824) | | |__ | | |--Allen MCCOY | (1838 - ....) | __ | | | _Reuben SMITH _______| | | (1767 - 1840) m 1788| | | |__ | | |_Mary Ann D. SMITH ______| (1805 - 1892) m 1825 | | __ | | |_Sarah Beach CLARK __| (1773 - 1834) m 1788| |__
_Alexander MCCOY ____ | (1770 - 1841) _John Wingate MCCOY _| | (1794 - 1877) m 1828| | |_____________________ | _William MCCOY ______| | (1832 - 1903) m 1855| | | _Reuben SMITH _______ | | | (1767 - 1840) m 1788 | |_Elizabeth SMITH ____| | (1810 - 1880) m 1828| | |_Sarah Beach CLARK __ | (1773 - 1834) m 1788 | |--Almira A. MCCOY | (1857 - 1926) | _____________________ | | | _____________________| | | | | | |_____________________ | | |_Elizabeth JOHNSON __| (1839 - 1859) m 1855| | _____________________ | | |_____________________| | |_____________________
_Alexander MCCOY ____ | (1770 - 1841) m 1796 _Alexander MCCOY ____| | (1815 - 1897) m 1862| | |_Hannah MCCULLOUGH __+ | (.... - 1815) m 1796 _John O. MCCOY ____________________| | (1864 - 1900) m 1885 | | | _____________________ | | | | |_Mary DUNKEL ________| | (1824 - 1897) m 1862| | |_____________________ | | |--Alta E. MCCOY | (1885 - ....) | _____________________ | | | _____________________| | | | | | |_____________________ | | |_Nora B. (Lenora Isabell) SPURGIN _| (1868 - 1939) m 1885 | | _____________________ | | |_____________________| | |_____________________
_Isaac MCCOY ________ | (1756 - 1797) _Thomas Jefferson MCCOY _| | (1789 - 1861) m 1825 | | |_Lydia GADDIS _______ | (1766 - 1824) _Isaac MCCOY ________| | (1828 - 1904) m 1854| | | _Reuben SMITH _______ | | | (1767 - 1840) m 1788 | |_Mary Ann D. SMITH ______| | (1805 - 1892) m 1825 | | |_Sarah Beach CLARK __ | (1773 - 1834) m 1788 | |--Anna Margaret MCCOY | (1866 - 1866) | _____________________ | | | _________________________| | | | | | |_____________________ | | |_Lucinda ALLEN ______| (1836 - 1920) m 1854| | _____________________ | | |_________________________| | |_____________________
Apparently married a Stewart and was widowed by the time of the 1870 census, when she is keeping house for her widowed mother Mary McCoy in Clark Co., IL. We did not locate her husband on the 1870 census. The marriage to Timothy Stewart, however, is in fact duly recorded in Clark Co., Illinois on 28 oct 1869, the same day the license was issued. Her tombstone in Bethesda Cemetery, Sugarcreek Tp., Vigo Co., IN indicates she was the wife of T. R. Stewart, but there is no burial for him.
__ | _Isaac MCCOY ________| | (1756 - 1797) | | |__ | _Thomas Jefferson MCCOY _| | (1789 - 1861) m 1825 | | | __ | | | | |_Lydia GADDIS _______| | (1766 - 1824) | | |__ | | |--Anne Marie (Mariah) MCCOY | (1844 - 1891) | __ | | | _Reuben SMITH _______| | | (1767 - 1840) m 1788| | | |__ | | |_Mary Ann D. SMITH ______| (1805 - 1892) m 1825 | | __ | | |_Sarah Beach CLARK __| (1773 - 1834) m 1788| |__
still living - details excluded
_Melvin Stoner MCCOY _+ | (1855 - 1916) m 1880 _Ralph Owen MCCOY ___| | (1881 - 1956) m 1917| | |_Nancy Isabel HILL ___ | (1856 - 1916) m 1880 _Earl Dean MCCOY _____| | | | | ______________________ | | | | |_Martha Oral SIX ____| | (1884 - 1958) m 1917| | |______________________ | | |--Anthony Scott MCCOY | | ______________________ | | | _____________________| | | | | | |______________________ | | |_Wanda Rita DE PIZZO _| | | ______________________ | | |_____________________| | |______________________
_Alexander MCCOY _____ | (1770 - 1841) _John Wingate MCCOY ________| | (1794 - 1877) m 1828 | | |______________________ | _John Wesley MCCOY _________| | (1834 - 1911) m 1856 | | | _Reuben SMITH ________ | | | (1767 - 1840) m 1788 | |_Elizabeth SMITH ___________| | (1810 - 1880) m 1828 | | |_Sarah Beach CLARK ___ | (1773 - 1834) m 1788 | |--Ara MCCOY | (1874 - 1952) | _James WHITESIDE _____+ | | (.... - 1847) m 1799 | _Isaac Slaughter WHITESIDE _| | | (1806 - 1882) m 1832 | | | |_Elizabeth SLAUGHTER _+ | | (1779 - 1835) m 1799 |_Louisa Adelaide WHITESIDE _| (1836 - 1903) m 1856 | | _David MCCOY _________ | | (1798 - 1829) m 1816 |_Georgette MCCOY ___________| (1816 - 1896) m 1832 | |_Louisa MARCEL _______+ (1799 - 1885) m 1816
_Alexander MCCOY ____ | (1770 - 1841) m 1796 _Samuel MCCOY _______| | (1797 - 1882) m 1819| | |_Hannah MCCULLOUGH __+ | (.... - 1815) m 1796 _George W. MCCOY ____| | (1831 - 1921) m 1869| | | _William PILSON _____ | | | (0175 - 1824) | |_Sally PILSON _______| | (1796 - 1835) m 1819| | |_Easter TURNER ______ | (0175 - 1813) | |--Arthur Alexander MCCOY | (1880 - 1954) | _____________________ | | | _James HARPER _______| | | (1810 - 1886) m 1822| | | |_____________________ | | |_Lucinda HARPER _____| (1839 - 1890) m 1869| | _____________________ | | |_Mahala GROVER ______| (.... - 1854) m 1822| |_____________________
_Alexander MCCOY ____+ | (1815 - 1897) m 1837 _George W. MCCOY ____| | (1839 - 1887) m 1861| | |_Emily HEMPHILL _____ | (.... - 1846) m 1837 _Frederick Woodson MCCOY _| | (1878 - 1947) m 1899 | | | _____________________ | | | | |_Huldah BRIGGS ______| | (1843 - 1925) m 1861| | |_____________________ | | |--Barbara MCCOY | | _____________________ | | | _____________________| | | | | | |_____________________ | | |_Rose O'CONNOR ___________| (1882 - 1964) m 1899 | | _____________________ | | |_____________________| | |_____________________
__ | _Alexander MCCOY ____| | (1770 - 1841) | | |__ | _John Wingate MCCOY _| | (1794 - 1877) m 1828| | | __ | | | | |_____________________| | | | |__ | | |--Barlow Aldrich MCCOY | (1844 - 1918) | __ | | | _Reuben SMITH _______| | | (1767 - 1840) m 1788| | | |__ | | |_Elizabeth SMITH ____| (1810 - 1880) m 1828| | __ | | |_Sarah Beach CLARK __| (1773 - 1834) m 1788| |__
_Alexander MCCOY ____+ | (1815 - 1897) m 1837 _George W. MCCOY ____| | (1839 - 1887) m 1861| | |_Emily HEMPHILL _____ | (.... - 1846) m 1837 _Frederick Woodson MCCOY _| | (1878 - 1947) m 1899 | | | _____________________ | | | | |_Huldah BRIGGS ______| | (1843 - 1925) m 1861| | |_____________________ | | |--Betty MCCOY | | _____________________ | | | _____________________| | | | | | |_____________________ | | |_Rose O'CONNOR ___________| (1882 - 1964) m 1899 | | _____________________ | | |_____________________| | |_____________________
_George W. MCCOY ____+ | (1831 - 1921) m 1853 _Samuel Turner MCCOY ___________| | (1860 - 1932) m 1880 | | |_Sarah HARPER _______+ | (1835 - 1868) m 1853 _George Joseph MCCOY _| | (1885 - 1945) m 1911 | | | _____________________ | | | | |_Mary (Molly) Elizabeth MCCABE _| | (1860 - 1947) m 1880 | | |_____________________ | | |--Betty Ann MCCOY | (1919 - 2001) | _____________________ | | | ________________________________| | | | | | |_____________________ | | |_Mary Alice COCHRAN __| (1889 - 1975) m 1911 | | _____________________ | | |________________________________| | |_____________________
_David C. MCCOY __________+ | (1841 - 1878) m 1864 _Oscar Reuben MCCOY ________| | (1865 - 1944) m 1892 | | |_Harriet (Hattie) WILSON _ | (1850 - 1928) m 1864 _George Sidney MCCOY __| | (1910 - 1972) | | | _Sidney William SCANLAND _ | | | (1835 - 1918) | |_Florence Zenobia SCANLAND _| | (1873 - 1938) m 1892 | | |_Louisa A. JAQUES ________ | (1839 - 1922) | |--Betty Lou MCCOY | (1937 - 1989) | __________________________ | | | ____________________________| | | | | | |__________________________ | | |_Geneva Elvena NORTON _| | | __________________________ | | |____________________________| | |__________________________
_David MCCOY ________ | (1798 - 1829) m 1816 _Thaddeus MCCOY _____| | (1822 - 1852) m 1844| | |_Louisa MARCEL ______+ | (1799 - 1885) m 1816 _Oscar MCCOY ________| | (1847 - 1905) | | | _____________________ | | | | |_Susan NIGHSWONGER __| | (1828 - 1880) m 1844| | |_____________________ | | |--Blanche Emma MCCOY | (1895 - 1973) | _____________________ | | | _____________________| | | | | | |_____________________ | | |_Laura E. SIDES _____| (1855 - 1949) | | _____________________ | | |_____________________| | |_____________________
still living - details excluded
_Melvin Walter MCCOY _______+ | (1886 - 1953) m 1912 _Ralph Edward MCCOY ______| | | | |_Luella Pearl Sophia GEITZ _ | (1889 - ....) m 1912 _Robert Allan MCCOY _| | | | | ____________________________ | | | | |_Melba Elizbeth MCKIBBEN _| | | | |____________________________ | | |--Bonnie Sue MCCOY | | ____________________________ | | | __________________________| | | | | | |____________________________ | | |_Carolyn MORGAN _____| | | ____________________________ | | |__________________________| | |____________________________
_Fred MCCOY _____________+ | (1868 - 1947) m 1898 _John Wyman MCCOY ___________| | (1898 - 1979) m 1921 | | |_Lillian Gertrude BAIRD _+ | (1875 - 1960) m 1898 _John Wayne MCCOY ___| | (1922 - 2023) | | | _Walter Moses VICTOR ____+ | | | (1865 - 1933) m 1892 | |_Gertrude Marguerite VICTOR _| | (1903 - 1993) m 1921 | | |_Eulia Rose May REEDY ___+ | (1877 - 1967) m 1892 | |--Bruce Edward MCCOY | | _Henry Nickey RICE ______+ | | (1843 - 1935) m 1866 | _William Jenner RICE ________| | | (1878 - 1962) m 1909 | | | |_Sarah Ellen REED _______+ | | (1845 - 1932) m 1866 |_Alice Eleanor RICE _| (1925 - 2020) | | _Thomas Julien BROCK ____+ | | (1852 - 1915) m 1879 |_Laura Claire BROCK _________| (1889 - 1944) m 1909 | |_Mary Jane REA __________+ (1858 - 1952) m 1879
still living - details excluded
_William MCCOY _______+ | (1832 - 1903) m 1863 _Elmer Elsworth MCCOY ___| | (1862 - 1947) m 1882 | | |_Susan Jane SCANLAND _+ | (1838 - 1930) m 1863 _Homer Walter MCCOY _| | (1894 - 1974) m 1919| | | ______________________ | | | | |_Sarah Isabella OSBORNE _| | (1864 - 1943) m 1882 | | |______________________ | | |--Carolyn MCCOY | | ______________________ | | | _________________________| | | | | | |______________________ | | |_Laura C. HOLMES ____| (1896 - 1963) m 1919| | ______________________ | | |_________________________| | |______________________
[1682] per 1880 census
_David MCCOY ________ | (1798 - 1829) m 1816 _Oscar MCCOY ________| | (1820 - 1844) m 1841| | |_Louisa MARCEL ______+ | (1799 - 1885) m 1816 _David C. MCCOY __________| | (1841 - 1878) m 1864 | | | _Moses STUART _______ | | | (1792 - 1874) m 1817 | |_Letitia STUART _____| | (1823 - 1844) m 1841| | |_Terressa CANNON ____ | (1801 - 1886) m 1817 | |--Carrie L. MCCOY | (1868 - 1920) | _____________________ | | | _____________________| | | | | | |_____________________ | | |_Harriet (Hattie) WILSON _| (1850 - 1928) m 1864 | | _____________________ | | |_____________________| | |_____________________
_Samuel MCCOY _______+ | (1797 - 1882) m 1819 _George W. MCCOY ____| | (1831 - 1921) m 1853| | |_Sally PILSON _______+ | (1796 - 1835) m 1819 _Samuel Turner MCCOY ___________| | (1860 - 1932) m 1880 | | | _James HARPER _______ | | | (1810 - 1886) m 1822 | |_Sarah HARPER _______| | (1835 - 1868) m 1853| | |_Mahala GROVER ______ | (.... - 1854) m 1822 | |--Catherine E. MCCOY | (1889 - ....) | _____________________ | | | _____________________| | | | | | |_____________________ | | |_Mary (Molly) Elizabeth MCCABE _| (1860 - 1947) m 1880 | | _____________________ | | |_____________________| | |_____________________
still living - details excluded
_Melvin Walter MCCOY _______+ | (1886 - 1953) m 1912 _Ralph Edward MCCOY ______| | | | |_Luella Pearl Sophia GEITZ _ | (1889 - ....) m 1912 _Robert Allan MCCOY _| | | | | ____________________________ | | | | |_Melba Elizbeth MCKIBBEN _| | | | |____________________________ | | |--Charles David MCCOY | | ____________________________ | | | __________________________| | | | | | |____________________________ | | |_Carolyn MORGAN _____| | | ____________________________ | | |__________________________| | |____________________________
[6410] However, information from Pat Fusselman says 1872.
_Alexander MCCOY ____ | (1770 - 1841) m 1796 _Alexander MCCOY ____| | (1815 - 1897) m 1837| | |_Hannah MCCULLOUGH __+ | (.... - 1815) m 1796 _George W. MCCOY ____| | (1839 - 1887) m 1861| | | _____________________ | | | | |_Emily HEMPHILL _____| | (.... - 1846) m 1837| | |_____________________ | | |--Charles Theodore MCCOY | (1861 - 1862) | _____________________ | | | _____________________| | | | | | |_____________________ | | |_Huldah BRIGGS ______| (1843 - 1925) m 1861| | _____________________ | | |_____________________| | |_____________________
_Alexander MCCOY ____+ | (1815 - 1897) m 1837 _George W. MCCOY ____| | (1839 - 1887) m 1861| | |_Emily HEMPHILL _____ | (.... - 1846) m 1837 _Frederick Woodson MCCOY _| | (1878 - 1947) m 1899 | | | _____________________ | | | | |_Huldah BRIGGS ______| | (1843 - 1925) m 1861| | |_____________________ | | |--Charles W. MCCOY | (1908 - 1912) | _____________________ | | | _____________________| | | | | | |_____________________ | | |_Rose O'CONNOR ___________| (1882 - 1964) m 1899 | | _____________________ | | |_____________________| | |_____________________